Why CFOs Get Surprised
The finance problem to watch for in MA network builds isn't overspending. It's underbudgeting at the outset, then spending reactively, under worse conditions, when gaps create compliance pressure or threaten an application: expedited contracting on less favorable terms, overtime in credentialing, and legal and communications costs.
Network build costs often reach finance as a vague line item, "provider recruitment and contracting," with no breakdown to weigh against the return. This post is that breakdown. We don't print dollar figures, because we haven't found a public benchmark we would stand behind. Use your own salary bands and vendor quotes.
Staffing: The Largest and Most Variable Cost
For a plan building or significantly expanding a network, staffing is usually the primary cost driver. The functional roles:
- Network Development Director: Owns the strategy, manages vendor relationships, is accountable to leadership for gap closure timelines. This is not a role to fill with a generalist.
- Provider Relations Specialists: The outreach and contracting workhorses. Size this team from your own gap list: how many providers need contacting, how many touches each, and how many live conversations one person can carry.
- Credentialing Coordinators: Often underinvested. A backlog here leaves signed providers who can't yet see members on the date you need them.
- Data and Analytics Support: Network adequacy is a data problem. Plans without dedicated analytics support for gap analysis, access modeling, and CMS reporting are flying blind.
Fully load these roles with benefits, overhead, and management allocation. An understaffed build usually produces gaps that cost more to fix later.
Technology: Often Underinvested Until It's Painful
The core technology for a network build program falls into three categories:
- Provider directory management: NPI validation, panel status tracking, verification dates, and records of who confirmed what. The 90-day verification rules (commercial today, MA from plan year 2028) apply provider by provider.
- Network adequacy modeling: Maps your contracted network against CMS standards by county and specialty. Ask every vendor how distance is measured, and whether drive time is measured at all. Without modeling, you discover gaps at submission, not during the build.
- CRM or outreach management: Tracking outreach sequences, contact history, and contract status across many simultaneous conversations is not a job for email and spreadsheets.
Signing Bonuses, Legal, and Contingency
Three additional cost categories that can surprise finance teams:
Rate exceptions and incentives: For specialties where you have little leverage, contracting may require above-floor rates or one-time incentives. Budget a reserve, and decide up front who can approve drawing on it.
Legal and credentialing fees: Contract review, hospital system negotiations, and credentialing delegation agreements generate real legal cost. Get an estimate from counsel before the build starts.
Contingency reserve: Network builds run into surprises: a key specialist group declines, a hospital system terminates mid-build, a gap opens due to a provider retirement. A contingency is not padding. It's what lets you close a gap before the upload rather than after.
The Return That Makes This Investment Rational
Weigh the cost against what the network enables, using your own inputs:
- New member revenue: Projected members in the counties the network opens, times expected revenue per member per month. Compare that to the build cost for those counties.
- A denied county: MedPAC's June 2024 report says CMS has never imposed intermediate sanctions or civil money penalties for network adequacy noncompliance, "However, new applications have been denied on this basis." For an expansion, the realistic downside is a year of lost enrollment in that county, not a fine.
- Star Ratings: According to KFF, contracts rated at least 4 stars get a higher benchmark, usually by 5 percentage points, and star ratings also set the share of savings kept as rebates. Access-related member survey measures are one input among many, so treat this as a risk to model, not a return to promise.
Network build is a capital allocation decision that deserves the same rigor as any other growth investment. Make that case before a review forces it.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.
