It Starts With an Automated Check
When you upload HSD tables to the Network Management Module (NMM) in HPMS, CMS's Automated Criteria Check (ACC) scores every provider and facility type in every county. CMS's December 2024 guidance and the application materials describe the process, and a lot of what circulates about it is guesswork, so here is only what is on the record.
What the Check Measures
For each county and type, there are two tests under 42 CFR 422.116: a minimum count, and time and distance. At least 90% of beneficiaries in Large Metro and Metro counties, and 85% in Micro, Rural, and CEAC counties, must have a provider of that type within both the maximum time and the maximum distance.
The beneficiary side uses CMS's MA Medicare Sample Census, which CMS says is "only available to CMS." The provider side uses your addresses exactly as typed. That is why data quality matters so much: CMS's 2017 criteria guidance described an Address Information Report where an address the software couldn't locate could be placed at a generated point in the ZIP, and an invalid address with a bad ZIP left out of automated processing. Check the current NMM Plan User Guide for today's wording, and read that report every cycle. See why your network passes internally and fails CMS.
What Happens Next Depends on Who You Are
If you are an applicant, the network has to pass inside the application. The review runs in three HSD upload rounds: the initial submission, the response to CMS's deficiency notice, and the response to the Notice of Intent to Deny. Each goes back through the ACC. The third is the last, and 42 CFR 422.502(c)(2)(ii) gives 10 days to respond. CMS may deny the application based on its network evaluation. Letters of intent can stand in for signed contracts during this review, and a 10 percentage point credit applies to the percentage test, but both end when the contract year starts. See the service area expansion timeline.
If you are an operating contract, CMS reviews on a triennial basis, and contracts due for review are prompted to upload their full HSD tables in mid-June. An application, a significant termination, a network access complaint, or a gap you disclose can trigger a review early. Contracts that fail may face compliance or enforcement actions.
If you need an exception, it goes in on CMS's current template in HPMS, one county and one specialty at a time, and it has to meet 422.116(f). Plans must resubmit all previously approved exceptions whenever CMS requests an HSD upload. Read how to request an exception first.
What You Can Do
- Test before the formal review. Any organization with a contract ID can upload to NMM at any time, and CMS offers an informal Consultation upload before the formal triennial review.
- Read the reports. Compare the ACC to your internal numbers county by county, and read the ZIP Code Report for Failed Counties to see where misses cluster.
- Keep provider data current. If a provider retires, relocates, or terminates, update your records right away. Notify your CMS Account Manager of terminations you consider significant.
- Spot-check your listings. Call providers in counties you consider marginal. The ACC doesn't test whether anyone answers the phone, but your members will.
An internal pass is a hypothesis. It becomes a pass when CMS's engine, run on the same tables you will submit, says so.
Understanding the mechanics doesn't change the underlying standards, but it changes how you prepare. Treat the upload as something you rehearse, not as the finish line.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.