Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildA failed adequacy review isn't the end, but how you respond matters a great deal. Here's the playbook.
When a network adequacy deficiency notice arrives, from CMS for an MA or QHP filing, or from a state Medicaid agency for a managed care contract, the temptation is to immediately escalate to legal and executive leadership and begin drafting a response. Resist that temptation for 48 hours. The first priority is understanding exactly what failed before you respond to anything.
Read the deficiency notice carefully and produce a structured summary that answers: which counties failed, which specialty categories failed in each county, whether the failure is a data error (your submission was wrong) or a genuine network gap (you don't have the providers), and what the cure deadline is. Take the deadline from the notice itself. For an applicant, the final chance is the response to CMS's Notice of Intent to Deny, and 42 CFR 422.502(c)(2)(ii) allows 10 days for it. Knowing the timeline is critical before you can plan the response.
The structured summary becomes the working document for your response strategy. Distribute it to the network ops team, legal, and compliance leadership with a clear read-the-document expectation before the first response planning meeting. Walking into that meeting without everyone having read the actual notice is a waste of everyone's time.
Deficiency notices come in two fundamentally different types, and your response strategy differs significantly between them:
Many deficiency notices involve a mix of both types. Identify which deficiencies are data corrections versus genuine gaps in your 48-hour analysis. Cure the data deficiencies immediately in your response: don't concede a data error as a genuine gap, because that concession affects how the regulator views the severity of your overall filing.
For genuine network gaps, your response must include a concrete remediation plan. Prioritize gaps in this order for emergency recruitment:
Emergency contracting timelines are compressed. Applicants may use letters of intent signed by both parties during the review under 42 CFR 422.116(d)(7). Operating contracts need fully executed contracts on the HSD tables. You are unlikely to recruit a hard specialty inside a short response window, so be honest in your response about what is signed and what is still in progress.
For the 15 specialty types listed in 42 CFR 422.116(d)(5), contracted telehealth providers earn a 10 percentage point credit toward the required share of beneficiaries in a county. That credit can close a gap that is within 10 points of the threshold, but it does not by itself cure a larger deficiency. Where you rely on telehealth, in the credit or as an alternative arrangement in an exception request, have ready:
For genuine gaps you cannot cure within the response window, your response needs facts. Include a complete outreach log from the original build (dates, contacts, methods, outcomes), any outreach since the notice, and an analysis of who is actually inside the standard. Records like these won't win an exception on their own: under 42 CFR 422.116(f), the test is whether the needed providers are available, and CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not a valid reason.
In 2021, the most common reason CMS denied exception requests was providers the plan failed to include on the request or HSD tables, according to MedPAC's June 2024 report. So account for every provider inside the standard before you respond.
Your formal response should be organized around the structure of the deficiency notice itself: address each deficiency finding individually, in order, with a clear statement of: (1) whether you are curing the deficiency with corrected data, an executed provider contract, or a corrective action plan; (2) the specific action taken or committed to; and (3) the timeline for full cure where the deficiency cannot be immediately resolved.
Include all supporting documentation as labeled exhibits that correspond to the deficiency findings. Make it easy for a reviewer to verify each assertion in the response.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.