Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildCMS's time and distance rules and the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) ask different questions about a behavioral health network. Here's how the two frameworks differ and what each one looks at.
The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008, as amended by the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021, requires that group health plans and insurance issuers not impose treatment limitations on mental health or substance use disorder (MH/SUD) benefits that are more restrictive than the predominant limitations applied to substantially all medical/surgical benefits. That reaches beyond copayments to non-quantitative treatment limitations (NQTLs), and plans covered by the law must perform comparative analyses of those limits.
The 2024 Final Rule, as written, made the network side of parity more concrete by treating network composition as a type of NQTL. But its status has changed. In May 2025, the Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and the Treasury announced that they would not enforce the parts of the 2024 rule that are new compared with the 2013 rule while they reconsider it. The 2013 rule and the comparative analysis obligation remain in place. Check the current status before relying on any summary, including this one.
MHPAEA and the Medicare Advantage adequacy rules at 42 CFR 422.116 are separate frameworks, and passing one says nothing about the other. Parity reaches different lines of business in different ways, so plans with more than one product should have counsel confirm which parity rules apply to each. Don't assume a parity analysis belongs in a Medicare Advantage filing, or that a CMS pass settles a commercial parity question.
CMS time-distance standards for behavioral health establish maximum geographic distance and travel time thresholds for psychiatry, licensed clinical social work, and psychology, evaluated county by county against limits that depend on the county's CMS designation: Large Metro, Metro, Micro, Rural, or CEAC. Meeting these thresholds means that a contracted provider is within both the maximum time and the maximum distance for the required share of beneficiaries in each county: 90% in Large Metro and Metro counties, 85% in Micro, Rural, and CEAC counties. This is a supply-side measurement: is there a provider close enough?
The MHPAEA question for plans it covers is different. It calls for a comparative analysis that asks: are the factors that determine the composition and depth of the behavioral health network the same factors applied to the medical/surgical network? If a plan uses different standards for credentialing behavioral health providers, different panel size requirements, different network adequacy ratios, or different access standards than it uses for medical/surgical benefits, those differences constitute potential NQTLs that must be analyzed and justified.
A plan can end up applying more restrictive standards to behavioral health networks than to medical/surgical networks simply because behavioral health provider contracting has been managed separately, often through a carve-out arrangement with a behavioral health organization (BHO) or specialty managed behavioral health organization (MBHO). When a BHO applies its own network standards, those standards may not be calibrated to the same benchmarks the plan applies to its medical/surgical network, creating a difference that is difficult to justify in a comparative analysis.
For plans subject to MHPAEA, several kinds of limits can create access differences between behavioral health and medical/surgical benefits.
A comparative analysis addresses each NQTL in the behavioral health benefit, identifies the factors and processes used to develop and apply it, and compares them to the factors and processes used for medical/surgical benefits in the same classification. Because the Departments are reconsidering the 2024 rule, have counsel confirm which required elements apply to your plan today.
For network teams, the practical point is that this documentation has to be kept up as you go, not assembled after a regulator asks. Capture the factors used for behavioral health network decisions and compare them with the approach used for medical/surgical networks, and update the record when network standards change or a significant contracting decision is made.
The analysis should also reflect the network you actually have, not just your stated policies. If the written recruitment standard is comparable but the behavioral health recruitment effort is weaker in practice, the written standard won't tell the whole story.
Plans dealing with both frameworks need documentation that meets the separate needs of each one. CMS documentation centers on HSD tables, provider counts by county and specialty, time and distance results, and exception requests for counties that cannot meet the standard. MHPAEA documentation centers on the factors and processes that produced the network and how they compare to the medical/surgical approach.
It can help to review both together for any plan subject to both. The CMS side covers time and distance results, provider counts by county, exception status, and the plan for closing gaps. The MHPAEA side covers network composition factors, the comparison with medical/surgical, and outcome measures such as appointment wait times, panel availability, and prior authorization approval rates.
A shared review also helps internally. When compliance, network operations, and clinical leadership look at behavioral health in one place, they are less likely to work from conflicting pictures, and issues can surface while targeted contracting or a policy change can still fix them.
Thin behavioral health supply is a structural challenge that contracting strategy alone can't fully solve.
In sparse markets, the supply of contracted psychiatric providers can be so thin that a plan faces a real tension: the CMS standards may be met with one or two contracted psychiatrists in a county, while those same psychiatrists may be too full to take new patients. The HSD result looks fine and members still can't get in. Since the CY2024 rule, 42 CFR 422.112(a)(6)(i) also sets appointment wait-time standards for behavioral health in MA, so that gap is a compliance question as well as an access one.
Plans in these markets should explore options that expand effective access with the workforce available, such as community mental health center contracting and collaborative care. Telehealth can help members, but in MA it earns a 10 percentage point credit for listed specialties under 42 CFR 422.116(d)(5), not coverage: telehealth-only providers don't count toward minimum counts and aren't physical locations for time and distance purposes.
Blueprint scores CMS's behavioral health types, including psychiatry, clinical psychology, clinical social work and outpatient behavioral health, by county against the HSD standards on straight-line distance, showing a straight-line pass as unconfirmed. It doesn't perform MHPAEA analysis, which stays with your compliance team and counsel.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.