Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildMedicare Advantage directories now have dated federal requirements: 30-day updates, an annual attestation, and a statute coming in 2028. Here's what the rules say and what compliance looks like in practice.
Provider directory accuracy is not a best practice: it is a federal requirement. The biggest recent change is 42 CFR 422.111(m), finalized in September 2025 and applicable to plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2026. MA organizations must make their directory information available to CMS for publication online, submit it in the format and timing CMS sets, update it within 30 days of becoming aware of a change, and attest at least annually that what they submitted is accurate. In practice, your directory now sits inside Medicare Plan Finder. Separately, the Provider Directory API under 42 CFR 422.120 has been required since January 1, 2021.
The rationale is straightforward: a provider directory is how a member selects a plan and finds care within it. If a member chooses a plan because their physician appears in the directory, and that physician has since left the network, the member has been misled about what the coverage offers.
Plans operating Medicare Advantage contracts should also be aware that directory accuracy requirements exist at the state level for commercial and Medicaid lines of business, often with different update cadences and data element standards. This article focuses on the MA regulatory framework, but network ops teams managing multi-line books of business should maintain line-of-business-specific compliance matrices.
Two MA rules set a 30-day clock. Under 42 CFR 422.111(m), plans must update directory data within 30 days of becoming aware of a change. Under 42 CFR 422.120, the Provider Directory API must be updated no later than 30 calendar days after the plan receives new information. Treat a termination, a new provider, a moved practice, or a change in whether the provider is accepting new patients as a change that starts the clock.
Those clocks run from when the plan learns of the change, not from when someone finishes processing it. If a provider submits a termination letter on March 1, plan as if the directory must reflect it by March 31, regardless of where your credentialing or provider data team is in the workflow. Provider data changes that sit in a queue for batch processing can miss this window.
The fix is a short path between the system that learns of a change and the member-facing directory. Plans whose systems only batch-process changes need a manual queue for urgent directory updates.
Don't limit this to formal credentialing submissions. If a member calls to report that their physician is no longer at a listed address, treat that call as notice of a possible change and start a verification. Train member services staff to route directory discrepancy reports to provider data teams, not simply note them in the member's service record.
Outside reviewers keep finding the same problem. In the third round of its MA online directory reviews (November 2017 to July 2018), CMS found that 48.74% of 10,504 provider locations had at least one inaccuracy. In May 2023, the Senate Finance Committee's majority staff published a secret shopper study of MA mental health listings and reported that more than 80% of listed in-network providers were unreachable, not accepting new patients, or not in network.
HHS-OIG's October 2025 report (OEI-02-23-00540) came at it from claims data. On average, 55% of the behavioral health providers listed by the MA plans it reviewed furnished no services to the plan's enrollees in 2023.
Plans should run their own secret shopper program: call the listed number, ask whether the provider is accepting new patients in the plan, and verify the address and specialty, as a member would. An internal program gives the plan an independent view of accuracy beyond attestations, and a record of its own effort. Use a random sample big enough for your directory, and track results over time.
We haven't found a published CMS numerical tolerance for directory errors, so be wary of any summary that quotes one. Under 42 CFR 422.111(m), plans attest annually to accuracy. CMS has said the CY2027 attestation reflects "reasonable, good-faith efforts" and does not require error-free data. A number is coming: under Section 6220 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026, the REAL Health Providers Act, plans must run an annual accuracy analysis and report an accuracy score to CMS starting with plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2028, and CMS posts the scores for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2029.
Measure at the listing level: a listing is accurate only if every required element is correct. A listing with the correct address but the wrong phone number still fails the member. Errors compound across fields, so a plan that looks strong on each field separately can look much weaker listing by listing.
Not all errors do the same harm. A provider listed as accepting new patients who isn't causes members to try to establish care and get turned away. A suite number that changed within the same building is a smaller problem. Fix the most harmful categories first.
Under 42 CFR 422.111(m), the data plans submit feeds Medicare Plan Finder, in the format and timing CMS sets. CMS validates the files, and a record with certain errors is suppressed on Plan Finder, so a formatting mistake can hide a contracted provider from people choosing a plan. Check the current regulation and CMS's technical guidance for what the plan's own online and print directories must contain and how they must be provided.
Accepting new patients is a directory field members rely on, and 42 CFR 422.111(b)(3)(i) requires MA plans to disclose providers' cultural and linguistic capabilities, including American Sign Language. If you display additional fields, such as group affiliation or telemedicine availability, maintain them as carefully as the required ones, because members rely on anything they can see.
If a plan offers a mobile app for finding providers, keep it on the same data as the web directory. Separate data feeds invite discrepancies, and a member doesn't care which one was wrong.
The errors that matter most are the ones that hurt a member. The clearest examples are: a member is turned away because the provider listed as in-network has actually left; a member incurs out-of-network costs because they chose a provider from an inaccurate listing; or a member cannot reach a specialist because the only listed specialist in their county is no longer practicing there. Under the REAL Health Providers Act, from plan year 2028, plans must hold members to in-network cost sharing when they relied on a listing that was in the directory on the date the appointment was made.
A member grievance or appeal that cites a directory error turns a data quality issue into a documented complaint, and under CMS's December 2024 guidance a network access complaint can pull a network review forward. Plans should have a way to tag grievances and appeals where a directory error played a part, and to feed that back into the directory update workflow.
The statute will raise the stakes. From plan year 2028, the REAL Health Providers Act requires network-based MA plans to verify each listed provider's directory information at least every 90 days, flag any provider they could not verify as possibly out of date, and remove a provider within 5 business days of determining the provider has left the network. Hospitals and other facilities the Secretary designates can be verified less often, but at least every 12 months.
A durable way to maintain directory accuracy is a systematic attestation program in which providers themselves confirm their directory listing on a regular schedule. It puts part of the work with the party who knows the practice first-hand, and it creates a record for the plan.
The 90-day verification in the REAL Health Providers Act is a good target to build toward. Send requests through more than one channel, such as a provider portal, email, and fax for practices without electronic options, and include a pre-populated form showing the current listing so the provider is reviewing their actual listing rather than completing a blank form.
Plans should define an escalation protocol for providers who do not respond to attestation requests. After two unsuccessful outreach attempts, the provider's "accepting new patients" status should be changed to "unknown" or "call to confirm" in the directory until attestation is received. After a third failed attempt, the plan should consider initiating a site verification call through its provider relations team. Providers who cannot be contacted for attestation over a sustained period may need to be reviewed for network participation status: a provider who is unreachable may no longer be actively practicing.
Attestation data should flow directly into the credentialing system of record, not into a standalone spreadsheet or attestation-only database. When attestation data and credentialing data live in separate systems, synchronization failures are almost inevitable. The credentialing system should be the single source of truth for provider directory data, with the member-facing directory drawing directly from that system in real time or through a tightly controlled nightly feed.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.