Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildThere is no good-faith waiver in CMS network adequacy. Under 42 CFR 422.116(f), inability to contract isn't a valid exception reason, however hard you tried. Your outreach records still matter. Here's what they're for, what to keep, and what the rule actually asks you to prove.
CMS isn't asking whether you tried hard. Its December 2024 guidance says inability to contract is not a valid exception reason, because the non-interference clause in Social Security Act section 1854(a)(6) keeps CMS out of plan and provider negotiations. Your outreach log still does two jobs: it tells you who is worth calling, and it gives you a dated disposition for each provider in range if a gap turns out to be a real supply problem.
What 422.116(f) asks you to show
What CMS's guidance rules out
Where requests fall apart
The exception test in 42 CFR 422.116(f) doesn't turn on a number of calls or emails, and we won't invent one. These steps are how we'd run recruiting and what we'd keep at each one. They're our practice, not a CMS requirement.
Confirm the contact
Call the front desk and ask who handles payer contracts and how they prefer to receive them. Outreach sent to a general inbox before you know that is often a wasted touch.
Ask for one thing
Ask for a yes to receive the agreement, then the signed agreement or, for a Medicare Advantage application, a letter of intent signed by both the plan and the provider. A packet that asks for everything on day one gives the reader no obvious first step.
Follow up on what's missing
Remind the practice only about what is still outstanding, by phone and in writing. Log each touch when it happens.
Record the outcome
End with a disposition for every provider: contracted, in recruitment, or not available for a listed reason. If it's a listed reason, get dated proof of it.
CMS's December 2024 guidance lists valid rationales and says the list is "not limited to" them. Write to the list anyway, because each item is something a reviewer can check. If the honest answer contains the word rate, you don't have an exception. You have a contracting decision.
| Reason | Under CMS's Guidance | What to Keep or Do |
|---|---|---|
| Deceased or retired | Listed | A license lookup or a dated outreach note. |
| Contracts with no organization, or exclusively with another | Listed | A letter saying so, or a dated call note. |
| Not practicing at the address in the supply file | Listed | A dated call note or a screenshot of the practice website. |
| Not practicing in the specialty the supply file shows | Listed | A license lookup or a dated call note. |
| Opted out of Medicare | Listed | A dated Medicare opt-out check. |
| On the OIG List of Excluded Individuals and Entities | Listed | A dated OIG exclusion search. |
| Enrollees are served by Original Medicare telehealth or mobile providers | Listed | Evidence of how enrollees in the county get this care today. |
| Specific community patterns of care | Listed | Claims data or a detailed explanation. |
| May cause beneficiary harm, or inappropriately credentialed under 42 CFR 422.204 | Evidence required | Accepted only with "substantial and credible evidence." It goes in as "Other," with the explanation in the notes field. A general quality concern reads as an internal standard. |
| Couldn't agree on rates, or declined your offer | Not valid | This is inability to contract. Keep negotiating, recruit someone else, or reconsider the county. |
| Still in negotiation | Not valid | CMS's 2017 template flagged this as not a valid rationale. Finish the contract or plan for the gap. |
| Fails the plan's own internal standards | Not valid | CMS's guidance says internal standards are not a valid reason to reject a qualified provider. |
| Never responded | Not listed | Silence doesn't show a provider is unavailable. Check whether a listed reason applies. If none does, keep working or recruit someone else. |
When it applies: Certain providers or facilities are not available in that county and specialty, as shown in the Provider Supply file
What it takes: Both halves at once: those providers are not available, and your contracted providers, possibly beyond the time and distance standard, are currently available and accessible to most enrollees, consistent with the local pattern of care
Outreach records can supply dated dispositions here. They don't replace the proof of supply or the pattern-of-care evidence.
When it applies: A facility-based institutional SNP can't contract with certain specialty types because of the way its enrollees receive care, or it provides adequate access through additional telehealth benefits
What it takes: The evidence CMS requires for this prong. Under (f)(3), an organization that receives this exception may offer only facility-based I-SNPs under that contract
If the contract carries other plan types, this door is closed.
When it applies: A partial county falls under the county integrity rule in 42 CFR 422.2, on CMS's Partial County Justification template. Dropping a county is a decision about where to operate
What it takes: A partial county must be necessary, nondiscriminatory, and in beneficiaries' best interests
"Inability to establish economically viable contracts" is not an acceptable reason for a partial county, per CMS's guidance and the CY2027 Part C application.
Outreach sequences send automatic emails and put calls and tasks on your team's lists, and each provider's history shows who did what and when. For a failing county, Blueprint can print a draft exception request for your team to review and file. It doesn't file anything, and a log won't excuse a gap.
Outreach history
Work on each provider is recorded, with who did it and when
Recorded decline reasons
A set list of reasons, so you can see who has a CMS-listed reason and who is really a rate problem
A printable exception draft
Available providers with CMS-accepted reasons, plus pattern of care, by county and specialty
Adequacy by county and specialty
Minimum counts and straight-line distance. A straight-line pass shows as unconfirmed, and drive time isn't measured