Start With the Right Questions
Most network builds begin the same way: someone pulls a county list, someone else exports a provider database, and the team starts working through which providers to contact in which counties. It is an understandable starting point. It is also the wrong one.
We'd start instead with a set of strategic questions that force the organization to confront its constraints before the outreach clock starts. If you skip them you find the answers anyway, at the worst possible moment: mid-build, when changing direction is expensive and options are limited.
Here are the five questions. Answer them before anyone sends a contract.
Question 1: What Is Our Realistic Submission Date, Working Backward From CMS Deadlines?
CMS sets the dates. For contract year 2027, applications were due February 11, 2026, and operating contracts due for triennial review are prompted to upload in mid-June. What you control is when your build starts, and that should be worked out backward from CMS's date, not forward from whenever leadership decides to kick off the project.
Working backward means accounting for your own credentialing timeline, the contract negotiation timeline (which varies by provider type), the outreach timeline, and the data validation timeline before submission. Use your own history for each. There is no reliable national average, and when you add them up honestly the answer is usually earlier than anyone wants.
Plans that ask this question first and answer it honestly will start earlier than plans that don't. That is the entire point.
Question 2: Which Counties Are High-Risk for Deficiency?
Not all counties require the same level of attention. CEAC counties, counties with known specialty shortages, and counties where your plan has historically had trouble recruiting providers deserve disproportionate early investment. These are the counties that will still be problems in month ten if you don't treat them as month-one priorities.
The county-risk analysis should run before outreach begins. Map your service area against provider density data, CMS county-type designations, and your own prior-year exception history. The counties that appear on all three of those lists as problems are the ones that need dedicated strategy, not just a larger outreach list, but a specific plan that may include telehealth, AMC contracts, or early work on an exception where supply really isn't there.
High-risk counties that get treated as routine counties produce deficiency notices. Plans that identify them early have time to develop real solutions.
Question 3: What Is Our Credentialing Capacity, and Does It Match Our Contracting Pipeline?
A plan can sign contracts faster than it can credential providers, and in most plans a provider isn't loaded as participating until the credentialing committee approves the file. A late credentialing queue means signed providers members can't see, regardless of how many contracts were signed.
Before the build starts, the credentialing team and the contracting team need to agree on a production rate: how many providers can credentialing process per month, and how does that match the contract-signing pace the outreach team is targeting? If contracting is projecting more signed contracts in a month than credentialing can process, that backlog needs solving in month one, not month six.
Question 4: What Is Our Exception Strategy for Markets Where Providers Won't Contract?
Some service areas will have counties where the county has only one or two providers who are already at capacity, where the specialty is in shortage, or where prior contracting relationships have soured. Pretending otherwise until month eleven is not a strategy.
This question forces you to sort those markets early, because they aren't all the same. Under 42 CFR 422.116(f), an exception needs proof that the providers aren't available and that your contracted network fits the local pattern of care, and CMS's guidance says inability to contract is not valid. A real supply gap may qualify. A provider who wants a rate you won't pay does not, and your options there are to pay, recruit someone else, or drop the county. See how to request an exception.
Question 5: Who Owns the Outreach Trail, and What Does "Documented" Mean in Our Organization?
"Documented" is doing a lot of work in most organizations. Sometimes it means a spreadsheet with call dates. Sometimes it means a timestamped record with contact method, outcome, follow-up date, and provider response. You want the second, both for running recruiting and because an exception request needs dated proof for each provider marked not available.
Before outreach starts, the organization needs to agree: what counts as a documented attempt, who is responsible for maintaining the record, and where the record lives. This is an operational decision, not a compliance decision, and it needs to be made by someone with the authority to enforce it across the contracting team.
Answer these five questions before starting a build and you'll have fewer surprises. Clarity on timeline, risk, capacity, exceptions, and documentation is not overhead: it is the build plan.
None of these questions are comfortable to answer, because the honest answers often reveal that the organization is starting too late, has insufficient credentialing capacity, or has markets with no viable contracting solution. But those constraints will surface eventually. Surface them in month one and you have time to respond.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.