The Fine Is Not the Number to Worry About
When a health plan gets a network adequacy problem, the first instinct is to ask about the penalty. MedPAC's June 2024 report says CMS has never imposed intermediate sanctions or civil money penalties for network adequacy noncompliance, "However, new applications have been denied on this basis." So the costs worth modeling are mostly somewhere else.
We don't print dollar figures here, because we haven't found a public benchmark we would stand behind. Use your own numbers. Here is what belongs in the model.
Cost Category 1: A Denied County and the Premium Revenue That Never Starts
Since contract year 2024, applicants for a new or expanding service area must demonstrate compliance as part of the application, and CMS may deny it. If that happens, you don't enroll in that county for the year. The arithmetic is simple:
- Take the members you projected in that county for the contract year.
- Multiply by your expected revenue per member per month.
- Multiply by the months you lose, and then ask how many of those members would have stayed the following year.
Enrollment suspension also exists as a sanction: 42 CFR 422.750 lists it among CMS's intermediate sanctions. MedPAC's report says that hasn't been used for network adequacy, so model it as a low-probability risk rather than an expected cost. The same arithmetic applies if you want to size it.
Cost Category 2: Remediation Work
A failed review creates work whether or not a sanction follows. CMS's December 2024 guidance says operating contracts that fail may face compliance or enforcement actions. Budget for:
- Staff and consultant time to rebuild tables, chase contracts, and manage repeat uploads.
- Legal counsel for the response and any regulatory engagement.
- Contracting on worse terms, because a provider who knows your deadline knows your leverage.
Cost Category 3: Broker and Employer Relationship Damage
Brokers talk. A plan that drops a county, or has trouble in one, can become a harder sell in that market. CFOs rarely put a number on this. Estimate it from your broker channel: what share of enrollment in the affected market comes through brokers, and how much of it would move? If you have group retiree accounts in the affected area, ask the same question about those.
The denied county gets the headline. Broker doubt is the cost that never shows up in the post-mortem.
Cost Category 4: Leadership Attention as a Finite Resource
This cost is real but rarely quantified. When a network problem lands, your head of network development, compliance leadership, and likely your CEO spend weeks in reactive mode. Strategic initiatives stall. New market entries get delayed.
The Total Picture
Add up your own numbers for a realistic scenario: a county you can't enter or can't keep, the remediation work, some broker attrition, and the leadership time. Compare the total to what it would cost to find and close the gap earlier.
The case for investing in network adequacy data, workflows and monitoring is not only a compliance argument. It is a financial risk calculation that many CFOs have never seen modeled.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.
