Two Buckets That Are Actually One Problem
Most CFOs at Medicare Advantage plans have two separate mental models: there's the compliance team's domain, CMS filings, HSD tables, network adequacy standards, and there's the Stars team's domain: HEDIS measures, CAHPS surveys, quality bonus payments. The compliance people worry about deficiency notices. The Stars people worry about member experience scores and medication adherence rates.
We think that separation is a mistake. Network adequacy and Star Ratings aren't the same thing, and a county passing the HSD test says nothing about how long a member waits. But they connect through the member. A gap in your network can become a member who answers the CAHPS survey badly, and that feeds your Star Rating, which sets your quality bonus.
That chain is plausible rather than proven, and we don't know of a published estimate of how much network gaps move Star Ratings. It's still worth modeling.
How the Chain Works, Step by Step
- Network gap: A county has thin behavioral health access. Members who need care can't get timely appointments.
- Member experience: Those members may answer CAHPS survey questions about getting needed care and getting appointments quickly less favorably. They are reporting their actual experience.
- Star Rating: Those CAHPS measures are part of the Star Ratings, alongside many other measures. Check CMS's current technical notes for their weights, which change.
- Quality bonus: According to KFF, plans rated at least 4 out of 5 stars get a higher benchmark, usually by 5 percentage points. Star ratings also set the share of the gap between benchmark and bid that the plan keeps as a rebate: 70% at 4.5 stars or higher, 65% from 3.5 to 4.5 stars, and 50% below 3.5. So dropping from 4.0 to 3.5 loses the bonus, and dropping from 4.5 to 4.0 cuts the rebate share.
The exact dollar impact depends on your benchmarks, membership and county mix, so run it with your own actuaries rather than borrowing someone else's per-member figure.
Modeling the Exposure
A CFO modeling network adequacy investment could run three scenarios:
- Scenario A: Current network gaps persist. Access-related CAHPS results stay where they are or slip.
- Scenario B: Targeted remediation in high-gap counties. Access-related results improve.
- Scenario C: A build started well ahead of filing. Fewer gaps at submission, and members can actually get appointments.
State your assumption about how much each scenario moves the rating, and test it, because that assumption is the weakest link in the model.
What This Means for How Plans Are Organized
We would make two organizational changes.
First, put network adequacy and Stars strategy under shared accountability. When the network build team and the quality team report to the same executive, or when their goals are explicitly linked in annual plans, the network build team stops optimizing purely for "no deficiency notice" and starts asking whether members can get appointments.
Second, build network adequacy investment into the multi-year financial model, not the annual compliance budget. Survey results lag the network, ratings lag the surveys, and bonus status is based on the prior year's rating. A decision made as an annual compliance line item doesn't match that timeline.
A plan cannot survey its way to 4.5 Stars if its members can't get appointments. Fix access first.
The case for building early rests on that lag. By the time an access problem shows up in a rating, it's too late to fix it for that year.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.