Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildA signed contract and a provider a member can actually see are different things. Here's how panel status, accepting-new-patients verification, and capacity fit alongside CMS's adequacy tests, and how network teams can keep a roster honest.
CMS's adequacy tests under 42 CFR 422.116 run on the contracted providers and addresses on your HSD tables: a minimum count and a time and distance percentage. Other rules reach what those tests don't. 42 CFR 422.111(m) requires directory data to be kept current, and 42 CFR 422.112(a)(6)(i) sets appointment wait-time standards for primary care and behavioral health. Treating "contracted" as "available" is how a network looks fine on paper and fails the members trying to use it.
We use two working criteria for availability. First, the provider accepts new patients who are enrolled in the plan. A provider who has signed a participation agreement but will not take on new plan members is not an option for a member looking for care. Second, the provider is reachable and operational: a provider with a current contract but an inactive practice location, or one on extended leave with no coverage arrangement, fails too. These are our criteria for a realistic view, not CMS definitions, so check CMS's current HSD instructions for how to list a provider who fails them.
Network operations teams should treat panel status verification, not just contract currency, as a core data collection requirement across primary care and the specialties where panel-level access is relevant.
An open panel means the provider is accepting new patients who are members of the health plan. A closed panel means the provider has reached their practical patient capacity and is not accepting new plan members, even if their contract with the plan remains in force. Partially open panels, providers who are accepting new Medicare patients generally but who have limited appointment availability within a particular plan, add additional nuance that network ops teams must account for in their verification protocols.
From an access perspective, a provider with a closed panel does nothing for a member looking for care, regardless of how long they have been contracted or how strong their historical participation has been. This creates a practical challenge: panel status is dynamic. A provider who was open at the time of outreach may close their panel before your next upload. A provider who was closed during the prior benefit year may have reopened. Capturing panel status as a point-in-time data element during outreach, and then re-verifying it as a CMS upload approaches, keeps your view of the network honest.
Plans should also be aware that panel closure can be plan-specific. A provider may be closed to new Medicare Advantage patients in one plan while remaining open to patients in a competing plan or to traditional Medicare. When conducting panel status verification, the outreach script must ask specifically about the plan in question, not about Medicare patients generally. Conflating the two is a data collection error that gives you a false picture of the network.
Panel size refers to the total number of patients currently attributed to or actively managed by a provider. Panel capacity refers to the maximum number of patients a provider can effectively manage given their schedule, support staff, and practice structure. The gap between current panel size and capacity defines the provider's headroom, the additional patients they could absorb, and it is headroom, not size, that determines whether a provider is genuinely open for new plan members.
We know of no CMS numerical panel capacity standard for an individual provider. Asking whether a provider is accepting new patients is the practical proxy for whether headroom exists. A primary care physician who is technically open but nearly full is unlikely to absorb meaningful volume. A network built heavily on providers who are open in name only may pass the adequacy tests while failing to deliver genuine access to enrolled members.
Network operations teams can track panel size alongside open/closed status during outreach, particularly for primary care providers in high-enrollment markets. That data informs contracting decisions about where to recruit additional providers before capacity constraints emerge.
We can't cite a published CMS checklist for panel status records, but the reasoning is simple. If anyone asks, including CMS, you need to show that you asked the provider rather than assumed. A current contract or last year's answer doesn't show that.
Good documentation of open panel status includes: the date of the outreach contact, the channel used (phone call, provider portal response, email), the name and role of the provider office staff member who confirmed panel status, and the specific question asked (i.e., whether the provider is accepting new patients who are members of the specific plan). Plans should keep this in their provider outreach records and be able to produce it on request. A spreadsheet notation that reads "open: verified" tells nobody who asked what, or when.
Plans should also document any discrepancies discovered during verification: cases where a provider was listed as open in the plan's system but outreach revealed the panel was closed, or vice versa. A record showing that the plan found and corrected its own data errors before an upload is worth having.
CMS gives telehealth a defined, limited role in the Medicare Advantage network adequacy framework. For the 15 specialty types listed in 42 CFR 422.116(d)(5), including psychiatry, clinical psychology, and clinical social work, a plan with contracted telehealth providers in that specialty receives a 10 percentage point credit toward the required share of beneficiaries within the time-and-distance standard in a county. Telehealth-only providers do not count toward the minimum provider count, and the credit does not by itself cure a deficiency. Within those limits, telehealth can meaningfully expand effective access in behavioral health, a category that has historically been among the most difficult to satisfy in rural geographies.
Outside the listed specialties, telehealth earns no credit, and in every specialty, physical provider presence within the applicable time-and-distance standard remains the primary counting criterion. Plans that have structured their network around telehealth-heavy delivery models should confirm against 422.116(d)(5) which specialty types qualify for the credit before relying on it in their adequacy filing.
The practical implication for panel capacity is meaningful: a contracted telehealth behavioral health group can support the telehealth credit across multiple counties simultaneously. However, the provider's panel capacity is finite regardless of their delivery modality. A telepsychiatrist who is at full panel cannot be counted as available any more than a brick-and-mortar psychiatrist who has closed their panel. Panel status verification applies equally to telehealth providers.
Outreach for panel status verification is most effective when it is structured and consistent. The outreach call or digital inquiry should include a standardized set of questions that capture not only open/closed status but also the nuance needed to make accurate adequacy determinations. A best-practice outreach script for primary care panel verification includes: confirmation that the provider is currently contracted with the plan, confirmation that the provider is accepting new patients who are members of the plan, an appointment availability check (for primary care and behavioral health, can a new member be seen within the wait-time standards in 42 CFR 422.112(a)(6)(i)), and a location confirmation to verify the practice address matches your HSD tables.
Appointment availability is a dimension of effective panel capacity that goes beyond the binary open/closed question. A provider who technically accepts new patients but cannot offer a new patient appointment for months is functionally inaccessible even if their panel is nominally open. The wait-time standards sit apart from the time and distance test, and CMS's automated check doesn't test them, but they are part of the same access picture. Network teams that capture appointment wait time data during outreach gain visibility into access quality as well as adequacy compliance.
Verification outreach should be conducted as close to the submission window as operationally feasible. Panel status can change in days, and a provider whose panel was open during initial contracting outreach six months before submission may have closed by the time the filing is prepared. Plans with large networks that cannot complete verification for all providers within a tight window should prioritize verification for providers who are the sole or primary contributor to adequacy in a given county: the providers where a closed panel finding would directly create a deficiency.
A scenario that network operations teams frequently encounter is the provider who has executed a contract and was counted in the plan's adequacy model during build, but who closes their panel between the contract execution date and the submission date. This scenario creates both a compliance risk and an operational response requirement. If the closing of that panel leaves the plan below threshold for the relevant county and specialty, the plan has an adequacy gap that must be resolved before filing.
The response protocol for a pre-submission panel closure should be immediately activated: the provider relations team is notified of the closure, the adequacy model is updated to reflect the provider's unavailability, and the gap analysis is rerun to determine whether other contracted providers can cover the threshold or whether additional recruitment is needed. Plans that can rerun their model quickly can see the impact of a closure and start on the gap while there is still time.
If the plan cannot close the gap through existing contracted providers, it should either accelerate contracting with an alternate provider or assess whether an exception fits. An exception request under 42 CFR 422.116(f) has to show that the providers needed to meet the standard are not available, and that the providers the plan did contract with are currently available and accessible to most enrollees, consistent with the local pattern of care. Inability to contract is not a valid reason. A pattern of panel closures across a market points to a broader network problem that needs its own recruiting answer.
Blueprint's provider portal can collect a practice's answers, including whether it takes new patients, and each provider's record keeps a history of who did what and when. Those answers don't change the adequacy score, which runs by county and specialty against the CMS 2026 HSD standards on straight-line distance and shows which providers a county depends on.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.