Free Network Build Assessment
Score your buildCounties with HRSA Health Professional Shortage Area (HPSA) designations are hard to build in, but the designation doesn't change CMS's standards. Here's what HPSA status does and doesn't do for your network build and your exception requests.
A Health Professional Shortage Area (HPSA) is a geographic area, population group, or facility that the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) has designated as having an insufficient supply of healthcare providers to meet the health needs of the residents or population served. HPSA designations are made under Section 332 of the Public Health Service Act and are maintained by HRSA's Bureau of Health Workforce. The designation is used across federal programs, including National Health Service Corps loan repayment, as an indicator that provider supply in a given area falls short of population need.
HPSA designations are made in three categories: primary care (physicians, physician assistants, and nurse practitioners delivering primary care services), dental care (dentists and dental hygienists), and mental health (psychiatrists, psychologists, clinical social workers, and licensed professional counselors). Each category is assessed independently, meaning that a county or service area may have a primary care HPSA designation without a mental health designation, or may carry designations in all three categories simultaneously. For Medicare Advantage network adequacy, the primary care and mental health categories are the ones that line up with provider types on CMS's list. CMS's list has no dental type.
HPSA designations are periodically reviewed and updated by HRSA as provider supply and population demographics change. A designation can be removed if a sufficient number of new providers enter the area and the shortage metric falls below the threshold for designation. Plans that cite a designation should check its current status with HRSA first, because a county that was designated at the time of a prior exception request may no longer carry that designation.
Each HPSA designation carries a numeric score from HRSA that reflects the severity of the shortage. Higher scores indicate more severe shortages, based on factors such as the ratio of population to providers and the share of the population in poverty.
For a network team, a score is useful context. It is public documentation that a shortage is recognized, and it can help explain why a county is hard to fill. It doesn't replace the evidence CMS actually asks for in an exception request, which is covered below.
Scores can also point to recruiting leads. The National Health Service Corps (NHSC) places providers in HPSA areas in exchange for loan repayment assistance, so plans recruiting in a designated county may find NHSC-placed clinicians worth contacting, especially where independent practice recruitment is difficult.
HPSA designation directly affects provider availability in the areas where it applies. The structural provider shortage documented by the HPSA designation means that the absolute number of providers available for recruitment is smaller than in non-designated areas, the providers who are present typically have full panels across multiple payers already, and new provider supply through training pipelines or market entry is constrained by the same factors that produced the shortage in the first place. For network adequacy purposes, this means that HPSA counties are genuinely harder to build adequate networks in, not because plans aren't trying, but because the providers aren't there.
CMS's time and distance standards come from each county's row in the HSD Reference File, and a HPSA designation doesn't change them. The same standards apply, with the same consequences for plans that fail to meet them. Any relief runs through an exception request, and the designation alone doesn't earn one.
There is one place the 2026 HSD Reference File notes do turn on shortage areas: physician assistants and nurse practitioners count toward primary care only in a narrow case, when they are fully credentialed as primary care, function as the enrollee's primary care source rather than supplementing a physician, and practice in or serve enrollees in a designated physician shortage area. Check the current notes before counting them.
Under 42 CFR 422.116(f), a supply-based exception has two halves that must both be true: certain providers or facilities are not available in that county and specialty, as shown in CMS's Provider Supply file, and the plan has contracted with other providers, possibly beyond the standard, who are available and accessible to most enrollees consistent with the local pattern of care. A HPSA designation can support that story. It doesn't prove either half.
A strong request for a county in a shortage area can include: the HPSA designation category and score, taken directly from HRSA's published data; a provider-by-provider account of everyone inside the standard, with the reason each one can't be contracted, such as retired, no longer at the location, or under an exclusive contract with another organization; a log of outreach dates, methods and outcomes; a description of the access arrangements the plan has made for members in the county; and what the plan will do next to close the gap. An inability to agree on terms is not a valid reason on its own, because CMS stays out of plan and provider negotiations.
Don't count on the designation to carry a thin file. According to MedPAC's June 2024 report, CMS denied 259 of 448 exception requests in 2021, about 58%, and the most common reason was finding providers within the criteria that the plan had failed to include.
The HPSA designation is often confused with the Medically Underserved Area (MUA) designation, which is a related but distinct designation maintained by HRSA under a different methodology. MUAs are geographic areas designated as having a shortage of primary care services as measured by an Index of Medical Underservice (IMU) that incorporates provider-to-population ratios, infant mortality rates, poverty rates, and the proportion of the population over 65. Where HPSA designations are specialty-specific (primary care, dental, mental health), MUA designations are population-focused and do not differentiate by specialty.
For MA network planning, HPSA designations are the closer fit because they are organized by type of care, as CMS's adequacy tests are. A primary care HPSA designation speaks to primary care supply; a mental health HPSA designation speaks to behavioral health supply. MUA designation is a more general indicator of access challenges.
A county can carry both designations, and an exception request can reference both as background. Neither replaces the provider-by-provider evidence CMS asks for.
Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs) are community-based healthcare providers that receive federal funding under Section 330 of the Public Health Service Act in exchange for serving all patients regardless of their ability to pay. FQHC locations can be a useful signal of where access is hard, and FQHCs can be stable provider organizations in designated counties.
FQHCs can be strong contracting targets in HPSA counties because they combine organizational infrastructure (FQHC status comes with federal grant compliance and governance that small independent practices may not have) with a mission to serve patients regardless of ability to pay. Confirm which clinicians and sites a contract would cover, and how each one fits CMS's provider types, before counting them.
A plan that has contracted with the FQHC in a HPSA county is in a different position than a plan with no provider in the county at all. Even if the contract alone doesn't bring the county up to the standard, it gives members real access, and it is the kind of contracted, available provider the second half of a supply-based exception request has to show.
Blueprint doesn't track HPSA designations, so pull those from HRSA directly. It scores each county by specialty against CMS's standards on straight-line distance, and for a county that fails, it prints a draft exception request for your team to review.
Blueprint automates the network build workflows described in this article: from adequacy modeling to provider outreach tracking. See it with your state and line of business.