Separate What's Published From What Isn't
A lot of what circulates about CMS's post-submission review is guesswork, including stage counts and day ranges nobody can source. So this piece sticks to what CMS has published, and flags what it hasn't.
The Automated Criteria Check
You upload HSD tables to the Network Management Module (NMM) in HPMS, and the Automated Criteria Check (ACC) scores every provider and facility type in every county against 42 CFR 422.116: the minimum count, and the share of beneficiaries within both the maximum time and the maximum distance. That share is 90% in Large Metro and Metro counties, 85% in Micro, Rural, and CEAC counties.
Three things about it are often misunderstood. The beneficiary locations come from CMS's MA Medicare Sample Census, which plans can't see. The criteria "are not restricted by state or county boundaries," so a provider across a line can serve your county. And no current public CMS document says whether the software routes on roads or measures a straight line, so treat your own distances as estimates.
The Reports to Read
CMS's 2017 criteria guidance described four statuses on the Address Information Report, including "Zip-Distributive," where the software couldn't find the street address and placed the provider at a generated point in the ZIP, and "Invalid Address," which left the provider out of automated processing. Check the current NMM Plan User Guide for today's wording. The ZIP Code Report for Failed Counties shows where misses cluster.
The practical implication is straightforward: list each provider at the office where they see patients for consultations, submit names and addresses exactly the same way each time, and validate NPIs and specialty codes before you upload.
Applicants: Three Rounds and a 10-Day Finish
Since contract year 2024, applicants must demonstrate compliance as part of the application. The network review runs in three HSD upload rounds: the initial submission, the response to CMS's deficiency notice, and the response to the Notice of Intent to Deny. Each upload goes back through the ACC. The third is the last, and 42 CFR 422.502(c)(2)(ii) gives 10 days to respond. CMS may deny the application based on its network evaluation. Dates are in our service area expansion timeline.
Operating Contracts: The Triennial Review and Its Triggers
Under CMS's December 2024 guidance, contract networks are reviewed on a triennial basis, and contracts due for review are prompted to upload their full HSD tables in mid-June. Four events can pull a review forward: an application, a termination CMS considers significant, a network access complaint, and a gap the plan discloses. Contracts that fail may face compliance or enforcement actions.
Where Exceptions Fit
Exceptions go in on CMS's current template in HPMS, by county and specialty, under 422.116(f). They are not a formality: MedPAC reports CMS denied 259 of 448 in 2021. Inability to contract isn't a valid rationale, and plans must resubmit approved exceptions whenever CMS requests an upload. Telehealth credits and the applicant credit each add 10 points to the percentage test in the cases where they apply, and neither touches the minimum count.
A Checklist
- Test before the formal review. Any organization with a contract ID can upload to NMM at any time, and CMS offers an informal Consultation upload before the formal triennial review.
- Assign someone to watch for CMS communications, with a backup, so a notice never sits unread against a fixed date.
- Keep provider data current. When a provider retires, relocates, or terminates, update your records, and tell your CMS Account Manager about terminations you consider significant.
- Start exception evidence early for real supply gaps. Ten days is not enough time to build a census.
- Run your own spot-check calls. Call providers in borderline counties to confirm they're accepting new MA patients and know they're contracted. The ACC doesn't test this, and your members will.
An internal pass is a hypothesis. It becomes a pass when CMS's engine, run on the same tables you will submit, says so.
Submission is not the finish line. Plan on more than one upload, and do the work that makes the later ones short.
The Blueprint team
Provider network build practice
Written by the people behind Blueprint, who between them have spent 30 years building provider networks for health plans: recruiting and contracting providers, chasing credentialing, and filing adequacy. Blueprint is new. The experience behind it isn't.
